SMB FX Playbook
Global Payroll Expansion: Entity vs EOR for SMBs

7 min read · Updated October 2026
An employer of record, often called an EOR, is a company in the other country that employs the person and runs local payroll while you direct the day-to-day work. Your own entity is a company you register there, so you become the employer. The choice is who holds the employment contract, who files payroll, and how much local administration you will own.
Key takeaways
- An EOR is a commercial contract with a local employer. It is not a government program, and it does not decide whether someone is really an employee.
- A local company makes you the employer. In the UK that means Companies House, then PAYE registration before the first payday.
- A US owner of certain foreign corporations may also have to file IRS Form 5471. A local company does not remove that US report.
- Use an EOR when you need a lawful local employer soon and you do not yet want your own directors, accounts, and payroll filings.
- Use your own entity when you will sign as the employer, hold local assets, or keep a team.
What does each path actually do?
On the EOR path, a local company hires the worker under that country's employment rules, pays them, and handles the withholdings it must handle. You pay the EOR a fee plus the employment cost. You still choose the person, set the work, and manage performance. Read the service contract for who can dismiss, who owns the intellectual property, and what happens if you stop paying the fee.
On the entity path, you register a local business and employ the person yourself. A payroll bureau can calculate pay and file returns while you remain the employer. The legal duties sit with your company and its directors.
Neither path is a contractor workaround. A genuine independent contractor is a different relationship. An EOR or a local company is what you use when the person should be an employee.
What does your own entity require?
Rules differ by country. The UK publishes enough of the steps to show the shape of the job.
GOV.UK says a private limited company is legally separate from its owners. Liability for company debts stops at the value of their investment. Register before you trade. Appoint at least one director and at least one shareholder, who may be the same person. Register an official address and a SIC code, and record people with significant control, including anyone with more than 25 percent of the shares or votes. The company pays Corporation Tax. Directors keep records, file a confirmation statement, file accounts, and file a company tax return. An accountant can prepare them. The directors stay responsible.
Employment is a second registration. HMRC says you register as an employer when you start employing staff, even if you employ only yourself as the sole director. Register before the first payday, and not more than two months before you start paying. The PAYE reference arrives by letter. If you must pay before it arrives, run payroll, store the full payment submission, and send it later. Staff also mean employer National Insurance, which Employment Allowance may reduce, and a workplace pension for eligible people.
Another country may add a local director, a notary, a tax number, and a bank account that opens only after the company exists. Budget that sequence.
A US owner or officer can have a US filing on top. Form 5471 is the information return certain US citizens and residents file as officers, directors, or shareholders of certain foreign corporations, under sections 6038 and 6046. A local tax return does not replace it. Ask a US adviser whether your stake and your role make you a filer before you incorporate.

How do you choose?
There is no universal headcount where one path becomes cheaper. Ask the EOR for a written fee and a list of exclusions. Put that next to an accountant's quote for local accounts, payroll, and filings.
An EOR fits when you need local employment law sooner than you can register, you are still testing one role, you do not need a local company to sign leases or invoices, and you have read the terms on dismissal, intellectual property, and who the worker is told employs them.
Your own company fits when the contract should be in your name, you need a local bank or tax registration, several people will stay, or a customer requires the contract to be with you.
You can use an EOR in a country you are testing and your own company where a team already exists. Do not also keep that person on a contractor agreement.
Example. You want a UK support lead next month and you have no UK company. Company registration, then PAYE before the first payday, takes a real sequence, and the PAYE reference arrives by letter. An EOR can employ the lead while you learn whether the role lasts. Moving them later onto your own company is a change of employer: notice, accrued leave, and a new contract.
Example the other way. You already invoice from a UK company and you are hiring three people who will stay. Employing them there, with payroll and a pension for eligible staff, matches duties you have. An EOR on top of that company is an extra layer. Price it on purpose.
What does the EOR leave on your desk?
You still manage the work. You still need cash in the currency the EOR will invoice, which may differ from your home currency. Plan that cash before the first invoice arrives.
The EOR does not classify other people in that country whom you pay as contractors. Keep the files apart.
If the EOR's local company is theirs, you typically do not own it, so you do not pick up its Form 5471. If you later form your own company, the US reporting question appears then. You still have a contract, a fee, and data-protection duties.
Confirm, before the person builds anything you need to own, whether they assign intellectual property to you, to the EOR, or to nobody.
Leave, notice, and working time follow the country of employment. Ask the EOR for the mandatory items in writing. On your own entity those items are yours. In the UK they include the payroll and pension duties above.
A sheet you can fill in
One row per country. Leave the money cells blank until you have quotes.
- Role, and the city where the person will work
- Earliest start date on an EOR quote, and the earliest start if you register first
- Who the legal employer would be on each path
- What you would sign, and who owns the work
- Ongoing filings: local payroll, local accounts, and any US Form 5471
- Exit: the notice period, and what happens to the person if you leave the country
If the employer cell or the exit cell is blank, you are not ready to hire.
Mistakes SMBs make paying overseas is worth reading before the first salary run, because a wrong account hurts a person.
If the person is still on a contractor contract, the tests are in Contractor Misclassification Risk When Paying Overseas.
FAQ
Is an employer of record the same as a payroll bureau?
No. A bureau calculates pay while you remain the employer. An EOR becomes the local employer. The contract should say which one you bought.
Do I still need a local company if I use an EOR?
Not to employ that person, if the EOR is the legal employer. You may want a company later to sign customer contracts, hold a lease, or hire in your own name.
What UK steps come with employing directly?
Register at Companies House before you trade. Register with HMRC before the first payday. Run payroll, pay National Insurance, and enrol eligible staff in a workplace pension.
Does a foreign company create a US filing?
It can. Certain US officers, directors, and shareholders file Form 5471. Ask a US adviser before you treat the company as only a foreign matter.
Can I move someone from an EOR onto my own company?
Yes, as a change of employer. Plan a new contract, notice, accrued leave, and a final pay from the EOR. Agree the date with the person first.
Should the first hire be a contractor so I can skip this?
Only when the work is independent under the tests where it is done, and under US rules if those apply. A contractor label does not convert a directed job into independent work.
When the role is staff, continue in payroll for international staff. When the person may be a contractor, use paying international contractors and freelancers. For the cash behind either path, read treasury basics for multi-currency SMBs.
